Awards in this category are given for an outstanding game taken as a whole that does not classify easily within other awarded genres such as Classic Revival, Franchise Action, Franchise Adventure, Franchise Family, Franchise Role Playing, Original Action, Original Adventure, Original Family, Original Role Playing, Fighting, Puzzle, Racing, Rhythm, Simulation, Sports, and Strategy.
| AWARDS | NOMINEE | WINNER |
| 2022-NAVGTR Awards | Endling: Extinction is Forever | Endling: Extinction is Forever |
| 2022-NAVGTR Awards | Marvel Snap | |
| 2022-NAVGTR Awards | Needy Streamer Overload | |
| 2022-NAVGTR Awards | Norco | |
| 2022-NAVGTR Awards | Vermillion | |
| 2021-NAVGTR Awards | Boyfriend Dungeon | |
| 2021-NAVGTR Awards | Inscryption | |
| 2021-NAVGTR Awards | Loop Hero | |
| 2021-NAVGTR Awards | Subnautica: Below Zero | Subnautica: Below Zero |
| 2021-NAVGTR Awards | Twelve Minutes | |
| 2020-NAVGTR Awards | A Fold Apart | |
| 2020-NAVGTR Awards | Coffee Talk | |
| 2020-NAVGTR Awards | Deliver Us the Moon | Deliver Us the Moon |
| 2020-NAVGTR Awards | Paper Beast | |
| 2020-NAVGTR Awards | Sakuna: Of Rice and Ruin | |
| 2020-NAVGTR Awards | Spiritfarer | |
| 2019-NAVGTR Awards | Bury Me, My Love | |
| 2019-NAVGTR Awards | Dreams | Dreams |
| 2019-NAVGTR Awards | Heaven’s Vault | |
| 2019-NAVGTR Awards | Neo Cab | |
| 2019-NAVGTR Awards | Sea of Solitude | |
| 2018-NAVGTR Awards | Florence | |
| 2018-NAVGTR Awards | Knowledge is Power: Decades | |
| 2018-NAVGTR Awards | Nintendo Labo | Nintendo Labo |
| 2018-NAVGTR Awards | Shadow’s Edge | |
| 2018-NAVGTR Awards | The Jackbox Party Pack 5 | |
| 2017-NAVGTR Awards | A Mortician’s Tale | |
| 2017-NAVGTR Awards | Dream Daddy | |
| 2017-NAVGTR Awards | Everything | |
| 2017-NAVGTR Awards | Getting Over It with Bennett Foddy | |
| 2017-NAVGTR Awards | Pinball FX 3 | Pinball FX 3 |
| 2016-NAVGTR Awards | Abzu | That Dragon, Cancer |
| 2016-NAVGTR Awards | Overcooked | That Dragon, Cancer |
| 2016-NAVGTR Awards | That Dragon, Cancer | That Dragon, Cancer |
| 2015-NAVGTR Awards | The Talos Principle: Road To Gehenna | The Talos Principle: Road To Gehenna |
| 2015-NAVGTR Awards | You Must Build a Boat | The Talos Principle: Road To Gehenna |
| 2014-NAVGTR Awards | Hitman Go | Monument Valley |
| 2014-NAVGTR Awards | Monument Valley | Monument Valley |
| 2013-NAVGTR Awards | Antichamber | Rain |
| 2013-NAVGTR Awards | Depression Quest | Rain |
| 2013-NAVGTR Awards | Device 6 | Rain |
| 2013-NAVGTR Awards | Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Dual Destinies | Rain |
| 2013-NAVGTR Awards | Rain | Rain |
| 2012-NAVGTR Awards | Crush 3D | Journey |
| 2012-NAVGTR Awards | Cubemen | Journey |
| 2012-NAVGTR Awards | Dyad | Journey |
| 2012-NAVGTR Awards | Journey | Journey |
| 2012-NAVGTR Awards | Lumines Electronic Symphony | Journey |
| 2012-NAVGTR Awards | Sound Shapes | Journey |
| 2011-NAVGTR Awards | Doc Clock: The Toasted Sandwich of Time | Swarm |
| 2011-NAVGTR Awards | Fruit Ninja Kinect | Swarm |
| 2011-NAVGTR Awards | Kung-Fu High Impact | Swarm |
| 2011-NAVGTR Awards | Spacechem | Swarm |
| 2011-NAVGTR Awards | Swarm | Swarm |
| 2010-NAVGTR Awards | Chime | The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom |
| 2010-NAVGTR Awards | Echoshift | The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom |
| 2010-NAVGTR Awards | Picross 3D | The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom |
| 2010-NAVGTR Awards | Puzzle Quest 2 | The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom |
| 2010-NAVGTR Awards | The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom | The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom |
| 2009-NAVGTR Awards | Flower | Flower |
| 2009-NAVGTR Awards | Peggle Dual Shot | Flower |
| 2009-NAVGTR Awards | Space Invaders Infinity Gene | Flower |
| 2008-NAVGTR Awards | Allen Carr’s Easyway to Stop Smoking | Buzz! Quiz TV |
| 2008-NAVGTR Awards | Buzz! Quiz TV | Buzz! Quiz TV |
| 2008-NAVGTR Awards | Cooking: Personal Trainer | Buzz! Quiz TV |
| 2008-NAVGTR Awards | My Weight Loss Coach | Buzz! Quiz TV |
| 2008-NAVGTR Awards | Scene It? Seinfeld Deluxe | Buzz! Quiz TV |
| 2008-NAVGTR Awards | Wii Fit | Buzz! Quiz TV |
| 2007-NAVGTR Awards | Crush | Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords |
| 2007-NAVGTR Awards | Mercury Meltdown Revolution | Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords |
| 2007-NAVGTR Awards | Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Trials and Tribulations | Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords |
| 2007-NAVGTR Awards | Picross DS | Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords |
| 2007-NAVGTR Awards | Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords | Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords |
| 2006-NAVGTR Awards | Big Brain Academy | Brain Age |
| 2006-NAVGTR Awards | Brain Age | Brain Age |
| 2006-NAVGTR Awards | Gunpey | Brain Age |
| 2006-NAVGTR Awards | Lumines II | Brain Age |
| 2006-NAVGTR Awards | Trauma Center: Second Opinion | Brain Age |
| 2005-NAVGTR Awards | Lumines | Lumines |
| 2005-NAVGTR Awards | Meteos | Lumines |
| 2005-NAVGTR Awards | Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney | Lumines |
| 2005-NAVGTR Awards | Trauma Center: Under the Knife | Lumines |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | Chessmaster 10th Edition | Feel the Magic: XY/XX |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | Feel the Magic: XY/XX | Feel the Magic: XY/XX |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | Wario Ware Inc.: Mega Party Game$ | Feel the Magic: XY/XX |
| 2003-NAVGTR Awards | Amplitude | Karaoke Revolution |
| 2003-NAVGTR Awards | Dance Dance Revolution Ultra Mix | Karaoke Revolution |
| 2003-NAVGTR Awards | DDR Max 2 | Karaoke Revolution |
| 2003-NAVGTR Awards | Karaoke Revolution | Karaoke Revolution |
| 2003-NAVGTR Awards | Wario Ware Inc.: Mega MicroGame$ | Karaoke Revolution |
| 2002-NAVGTR Awards | Cubivore | DDRMAX: Dance Dance Revolution |
| 2002-NAVGTR Awards | DDRMAX: Dance Dance Revolution | DDRMAX: Dance Dance Revolution |
| 2002-NAVGTR Awards | Magic the Gathering Online | DDRMAX: Dance Dance Revolution |
| 2002-NAVGTR Awards | Monopoly Party | DDRMAX: Dance Dance Revolution |
| 2001-NAVGTR Awards | Dance Dance Revolution: Disney Mix | Frequency |
| 2001-NAVGTR Awards | Frequency | Frequency |
| 2001-NAVGTR Awards | One Piece Mansion | Frequency |
| 2001-NAVGTR Awards | Who Wants to Be a Millionaire 3rd edition | Frequency |