Four awards are given for individual achievement in game-exclusive voice acting, honoring lead and supporting roles in games classified as comedy or drama.
| AWARDS | NOMINEE | WINNER |
| 2022-NAVGTR Awards | Evil Dead: The Game – Bruce Campbell as “Ash Williams” | Evil Dead: The Game – Bruce Campbell as “Ash Williams” |
| 2022-NAVGTR Awards | High on Life – Justin Roiland as “Kenny” | |
| 2022-NAVGTR Awards | Neon White – Steve Blum as “Neon White” | |
| 2021-NAVGTR Awards | It Takes Two – Annabelle Dowler as “May” | |
| 2021-NAVGTR Awards | It Takes Two – Joseph Balderrama as “Cody” | |
| 2021-NAVGTR Awards | Psychonauts 2 – Richard Horvitz as “Raz” | Psychonauts 2 – Richard Horvitz as “Raz” |
| 2021-NAVGTR Awards | Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart – Jennifer Hale as “Rivet” | |
| 2021-NAVGTR Awards | The Artful Escape – Michael Johnston as “Francis Vendetti” | |
| 2020-NAVGTR Awards | Bugsnax – Fred Tatasciore as “Wambus” | |
| 2020-NAVGTR Awards | Bugsnax – Kenna Ramsey as “Wiggle” | |
| 2020-NAVGTR Awards | Bugsnax – Max Mittelman as “Filbo” | |
| 2020-NAVGTR Awards | Immortals Fenyx Rising – Daniel Matmor as “Zeus” | Immortals Fenyx Rising – Daniel Matmor as “Zeus” |
| 2019-NAVGTR Awards | Trover Saves the Universe – Justin Roiland as “Trover” | Trover Saves the Universe – Justin Roiland as “Trover” |
| 2018-NAVGTR Awards | Adventure Time: Pirates of the Enchiridion – Jeremy Shada as “Finn” | |
| 2018-NAVGTR Awards | Adventure Time: Pirates of the Enchiridion – John DiMaggio as “Jake” | Adventure Time: Pirates of the Enchiridion – John DiMaggio as “Jake” |
| 2018-NAVGTR Awards | FIFA 19 – Adetomiwa Edun | FIFA 19 – Adetomiwa Edun |
| 2018-NAVGTR Awards | Pro Evolution Soccer 2019 – Peter Drury and Jim Beglin | |
| 2018-NAVGTR Awards | STONE – Ethan Watson as “Stone” | |
| 2018-NAVGTR Awards | UFC 3 – Jon Anik | |
| 2017-NAVGTR Awards | Battle Chef Brigade – Erica Mendez as “Mina” | Guardians of the Galaxy – Scott Porter as “Peter Quill” |
| 2017-NAVGTR Awards | Forza Motorsport 7 – Josef Newgarden | |
| 2017-NAVGTR Awards | Forza Motorsport 7 – Ken Block | |
| 2017-NAVGTR Awards | Guardians of the Galaxy – Scott Porter as “Peter Quill” | |
| 2017-NAVGTR Awards | NHL 18 – Paul Steigerwald | |
| 2016-NAVGTR Awards | FIFA 17 – Adetomiwa Edun as “Alex Hunter” | |
| 2016-NAVGTR Awards | King’s Quest Chapter V: The Good Knight – Christopher Lloyd as “King Graham” | King’s Quest Chapter V: The Good Knight – Christopher Lloyd as “King Graham” |
| 2016-NAVGTR Awards | NBA 2K17 – Michael B. Jordan as “Justice Young” | NBA 2K17 – Michael B. Jordan as “Justice Young” |
| 2016-NAVGTR Awards | Ratchet and Clank – James Arnold Taylor as “Ratchet” | |
| 2016-NAVGTR Awards | WWE 2K17 – Michael Cole as “Himself” | |
| 2015-NAVGTR Awards | Minecraft: Story Mode – Catherine Taber as “Jesse” | |
| 2015-NAVGTR Awards | Oddworld: New ‘n’ Tasty! – Lorne Lanning as “Abe” | |
| 2015-NAVGTR Awards | Tales from the Borderlands – Troy Baker as “Rhys” | Tales from the Borderlands – Troy Baker as “Rhys” |
| 2014-NAVGTR Awards | Broken Age: Act I – Elijah Wood as “Shay” | Broken Age: Act I – Elijah Wood as “Shay” |
| 2014-NAVGTR Awards | Professor Layton Vs. Phoenix Wright – Christopher Robin Miller as “Professor Layton” | |
| 2014-NAVGTR Awards | Professor Layton Vs. Phoenix Wright – Trevor White as “Phoenix Wright” | |
| 2014-NAVGTR Awards | Tesla Effect – Chris Jones as “Tex Murphy” | |
| 2013-NAVGTR Awards | Deadpool – Nolan North as “Deadpool” | |
| 2013-NAVGTR Awards | DuckTales Remastered – Alan Young as “Uncle Scrooge” | |
| 2013-NAVGTR Awards | Lego City Undercover – Joseph May as “Chase McCain” | |
| 2013-NAVGTR Awards | Puppeteer – Stephen Greif as “Narrator” | |
| 2013-NAVGTR Awards | The Stanley Parable – Kevan Brighting as “Narrator” | The Stanley Parable – Kevan Brighting as “Narrator” |
| 2012-NAVGTR Awards | Borderlands 2 – David Eddings as “Claptrap” | Borderlands 2 – David Eddings as “Claptrap” |
| 2012-NAVGTR Awards | Quantum Conundrum – John de Lancie as “Prof. Fitz Quadwrangle” | |
| 2011-NAVGTR Awards | Bastion – Logan Cunningham as “Rucks” | Bastion – Logan Cunningham as “Rucks” |
| 2011-NAVGTR Awards | Bulletstorm – Steve Blum as “Grayson Hunt” | |
| 2010-NAVGTR Awards | Bayonetta – Hellena Schmied | |
| 2010-NAVGTR Awards | DeathSpank – Michael Dobson | DeathSpank – Michael Dobson |
| 2010-NAVGTR Awards | Disney Guilty Party – Tim Dadabo | |
| 2010-NAVGTR Awards | No More Heroes 2: Desperate Struggle – Robin Atkin Downes | |
| 2010-NAVGTR Awards | Professor Layton and the Unwound Future – Christopher Robin Miller | |
| 2009-NAVGTR Awards | Brutal Legend – Jack Black | Brutal Legend – Jack Black |
| 2009-NAVGTR Awards | Ratchet and Clank Future: A Crack in Time – Armin Shimerman | |
| 2009-NAVGTR Awards | Ratchet and Clank Future: A Crack in Time – James Arnold Taylor | |
| 2009-NAVGTR Awards | The House of the Dead: Overkill – Anthony Aroya | |
| 2009-NAVGTR Awards | The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition – Dominic Armato | |
| 2008-NAVGTR Awards | Destroy All Humans: Path of the Furon – Grant Albrecht | |
| 2008-NAVGTR Awards | No More Heroes – Robin Atkin Downes | No More Heroes – Robin Atkin Downes |
| 2007-NAVGTR Awards | Hot Brain – Fred Willard | |
| 2007-NAVGTR Awards | Parappa the Rapper – Dred Foxx aka John Simpson III | |
| 2007-NAVGTR Awards | Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction – David Kaye | Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction – David Kaye |
| 2006-NAVGTR Awards | Al Emmo and the Lost Dutchman’s Mine – Christopher Warren | |
| 2006-NAVGTR Awards | Bully – Gerry Rosenthal | |
| 2006-NAVGTR Awards | Daxter – Max Casella | Daxter – Max Casella |
| 2006-NAVGTR Awards | Destroy All Humans! 2: Make War Not Love – Grant Albrecht | |
| 2006-NAVGTR Awards | Family Guy – Seth MacFarlane | |
| 2006-NAVGTR Awards | Pirates of the Caribbean: The Legend of Jack Sparrow – Johnny Depp | |
| 2005-NAVGTR Awards | Destroy All Humans! – Grant Albrecht | |
| 2005-NAVGTR Awards | Psychonauts – Richard Horvitz | Psychonauts – Richard Horvitz |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | Chronicles of Riddick: E.F.B.B. – Vin Diesel | |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas – David Cross | |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas – Peter Fonda | Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas – Peter Fonda |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas – Young Maylay | Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas – Young Maylay |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | Jak 3 – Max Casella | |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | Sly 2: Band of Thieves – Matt Olsen | |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | Splinter Cell Pandora Tomorrow – Michael Ironside | |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | Splinter Cell: Pandora Tomorrow – Dennis Haysbert | |
| 2004-NAVGTR Awards | The Bard’s Tale – Cary Elwes | |
| 2003-NAVGTR Awards | Evil Dead: A Fistful of Boomstick – Bruce Campbell | |
| 2003-NAVGTR Awards | Primal – Andreas Katsulas | |
| 2003-NAVGTR Awards | Primal – Hudson Leick | |
| 2003-NAVGTR Awards | Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic – Raphael Sbarge | |
| 2003-NAVGTR Awards | XIII – Adam West | XIII – Adam West |
| 2002-NAVGTR Awards | Grand Theft Auto: Vice City – Dennis Hopper | |
| 2002-NAVGTR Awards | Grand Theft Auto: Vice City – Ray Liotta | Grand Theft Auto: Vice City – Ray Liotta |
| 2002-NAVGTR Awards | Sly Cooper and the Thievius Raccoonus – Matt Olsen | |
| 2002-NAVGTR Awards | Spider-Man: The Movie – Bruce Campbell | |
| 2002-NAVGTR Awards | Toe Jam & Earl III: Mission to Earth – Greg Brown | |
| 2002-NAVGTR Awards | Toe Jam & Earl III: Mission to Earth – Kirk McHenry | |
| 2002-NAVGTR Awards | Toe Jam & Earl III: Mission to Earth – Sherrie Jackson |