Industry-Based
Resources
IGDA Credit Standards Wiki
IGDA Credit Debate Forum
Psychochild Blog
Eligibility Issues for NAViGaTR Awards
The
following guidelines for each category are not necessarily definitive. Due to
varying credit terminology in different countries or companies, as well as the extended collaboration
involved in team productions, the determination of proper eligible award recipients can be quite
challenging. Accomplishing this goal requires the Academy to commit to a workable
but imperfect process. The following guidelines shall serve as a first step in
that process, for which the Academy welcomes any participation. Individuals that are most likely to be eligible
for an award statuette are those with credited titles that are listed below as “Presumed
Eligible with Proof of Credit.” However, depending on the different meanings
of certain credits across different game genres, or depending on differences in the actual type
of development work performed in the creation of a unique game that would render a particular credit inapplicable, some
credits may occasionally be declared ineligible even if they are/were “presumed” eligible. However,
these cases should be extremely rare. Individuals with credited titles that are listed below as “Eligible with Permission”
may require permission from the Academy and, in some cases, permission from the nominees that are/were presumed eligible
and/or certified as eligible. However, if no one is presumed eligible (i.e.
no matching credit, or no credits on record), then the Academy may or may not waive the requirement
for proof of credit. However, if a waiver is granted, no more than three (3)
individuals will receive an award statuette, and reasonably supportive documentation of any kind
will have to be provided and held to be sufficient by the Academy. Future claims to an award may
require permission from the Academy and, in some cases, permission from the first three (3) individuals who received awards.
This process is likely to involve lengthy delays. For more information on receiving your award(s),
please contact info at navgtr dot org.
Outstanding Animation in
a Game Cinema
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE
W/POC: Lead Animators, Animation Supervisors, Animation Directors
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION: Animators
INELIGIBLE
CREDIT: Concept Artists, Art Directors, Artists
Outstanding Animation in a Game Engine
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC:
Lead Animators, Animation Supervisors, Animation Directors
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION: Animators
INELIGIBLE
CREDIT: Concept Artists, Art Directors, Artists
Outstanding Art Direction in a Game Cinema
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC:
Lead/Senior Art Directors, Concept Artists
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION: Art Directors, Background Artists, Artists
INELIGIBLE
CREDIT: Character Designers, Character Modelers, Costume Designers
Outstanding Art Direction in a Game Engine
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC:
Lead/Senior Art Directors, Concept Artists, Background Artists
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION:
Art Directors, Artists
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Character Designers, Character Modelers, Costume Designers
Outstanding Camera Direction
in a Game Engine
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC: Motion Directors/Programmers, Lead/Senior Programmers
ELIGIBLE
WITH PERMISSION: Programmers
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Producers,
Game Designers, Technical Directors
Outstanding
Character Design
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC: Character Designers, Concept Artists, Lead Character
Artists
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION: Character Artists
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Artists
Outstanding Control Design
PRESUMED
ELIGIBLE W/POC: Lead/Senior Programmers, Game Designers
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION:
Programmers, Technical Directors
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Battle Directors/Programmers, Artificial Intelligence
Programmers, Motion Directors/Programmers
Outstanding
Control Precision
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC: Lead/Senior Programmers
ELIGIBLE
WITH PERMISSION: Programmers
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Game Designers,
Battle Directors/Programmers, Artificial Intelligence Programmers, Motion Directors/Programmers, Technical Directors
Outstanding Costume Design
PRESUMED
ELIGIBLE W/POC: Costume Designers, Character Designers, Concept Artists, Lead Character Artists
ELIGIBLE
WITH PERMISSION: Character Artists
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Artists
Outstanding Direction in
a Game Cinema
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC: Movie Directors
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION:
Lead Animators, Animation Supervisors, Animation Directors
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Programmers,
Event Directors/Programmers, Technical Directors, Motion Directors/Programmers
Outstanding Game Design
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC: Game
Designers
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION: Additional Game Designers
INELIGIBLE
CREDIT: Producers, Programmers, Artists, Technical Directors
Outstanding Graphics, Technical
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC:
Lead/Senior Programmers
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION: Programmers, Technical Directors
INELIGIBLE
CREDIT: Producers, Game Designers
Outstanding
Innovation in Game Play
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC: Game Designers, Lead/Senior Programmers, Artificial
Intelligence Programmers
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION: Programmers, Battle Directors/Programmers, Technical
Directors
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Producers, Motion Directors/Programmers
Outstanding Innovation
in Game Technology
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC: Lead/Senior Programmers, Artificial Intelligence
Programmers, Inventors, Engineers, Patent Owners, Research & Development Employees
ELIGIBLE
WITH PERMISSION: Programmers, Technical Directors
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Producers,
Game Designers
Outstanding
Lighting/Texturing Effects
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC: Lead/Senior Programmers, Lead/Senior Art Directors,
Lead/Senior Artists, Background Artists
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION: Programmers, Technical Directors
INELIGIBLE
CREDIT: Producers, Game Designers, Concept Artists
Outstanding Original Musical Score
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC:
Musical Composers
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION: Musical Directors
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Sound
Designers, Sound Engineers, Singers/Vocalists, Lyricists
Outstanding Original or Adapted Song
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC:
Lyricists/Songwriters
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION: Dialogue Writers
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Singers/Vocalists
Outstanding Song Collection
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC:
Producers, Musical Directors
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION: Executive Producers, Asst. Producers
INELIGIBLE
CREDIT: Singers/Vocalists, Musical Composers
Outstanding Sound Effects
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC: Sound
Designers/Audio Directors, Sound Engineers, Sound Effects Creators, Foley Artists
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION:
Sound Mixers/Editors
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Musicians, Composers
Outstanding Use of Sound
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC: Sound
Designers/Audio Directors, Sound Engineers, Sound Mixers/Editors
ELIGIBLE WITH PERMISSION:
Game Designers
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Sound Effects Creators, Foley Artists, Musicians, Composers
Outstanding Lead/Supporting
Performance in a Comedy/Drama (4 categories)
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC:
Actors, Singers/Vocalists
Outstanding Writing in a Comedy/Drama (2 categories)
PRESUMED
ELIGIBLE W/POC: Story Writers, Scenario Writers, Script Writers, Writers, Dialogue Writers
ELIGIBLE
WITH PERMISSION: Text Writers
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Lyricists/Songwriters
Genre Categories (including original game awards, sequel awards, and simulation, special
class, strategy, and Game of the Year awards)
PRESUMED ELIGIBLE W/POC: Producers
ELIGIBLE
WITH PERMISSION: Assistant Producers
INELIGIBLE CREDIT: Executive
Producers, Game Designers, Programmers
Nov 14, 2011 --- Qualifying Ballot Released for 11th Annual NAVGTR Awards (Gamasutra)
Nov 14, 2011 --- Qualifying Ballot Released for 11th Annual NAVGTR Awards (Develop)